Economy vs The Market

Global development and the green economy as a businesss concept with a map of the world made of an organized group vine leaves growing on forest trees as an environmental conservation symbol.

Economy vs The Market

One of the most common investor concerns I hear is that they don’t want to invest until the economy improves.

If the market and the economy moved together they should have a correlation of close to 1, say 0.8. Correlation is measured on a scale of -1 to 1, with -1 being perfectly negatively correlated and 1 being perfectly correlated.  A number close to zero displays no correlation.

I did a correlation analysis of the S&P 500 vs GDP, quarterly and also non seasonally adjusted CPI, monthly.  I picked these times periods as GDP is released quarterly and CPI monthly.  I chose Jan 2007 as a measurement date as that was the year before the last financial crisis began.

Since January 1998, the S&P 500 and GDP has a correlation of 0.19.

Since January 2007, the S&P 500 and GDP has a correlation of 0.23.

Since Dec 1987, the S&P 500 and CPI has a correlation of -0.09.

Since January 2007, the S&P 500 and CPI has a correlation of -0.14.

What can we infer from this? The S&P 500 has almost no correlation to the changes in GDP and CPI.

I am not saying we run out and buy equities today because the GDP print shouldn’t matter to an investor, we should however pay attention to different variables.

One such variable is the Shiller PE ratio, or the Cyclically Adjusted PE Ratio, it is currently at a reading of 23.17. The long term average is 15.87.  This does not portend a market correction per se, but it should be of concern to an investor.

The price you pay for an investment has a higher influence on your return than what the “State” of the economy is.

Less headlines, more math…


Damien Lanyon

Damien is the founder and owner of Lanyon Advisory Services and has a extensive knowledge and experience in financial planning and wealth management.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.